Ep. 76 | Jim Chester, Gardner-Webb University

What You'll Learn in This Episode

Host Ross Hawley sits down with Jim Chester, head baseball coach at Gardner-Webb University in Boiling Springs, North Carolina. Chester grew up in the Pittsburgh area, played Division III baseball in the Northeast, and is now in his 20th season as a head coach, running a Big South program in a town where nobody is in a hurry once you pull off campus.

This one is a practical look at how a mid-major fall actually runs and how a roster gets built in the current landscape: the rules around fall outside competition, why Gardner-Webb opted out of the House settlement, the even split between high school recruits and transfers, what makes a high school player stand out, and the honest talk Chester gives freshmen before their first college fall.

The highlights:

• What one day in the fall looks like: individuals, mental performance work, and community service
• Why he would trade intrasquads for one outside game a week
• Play hard, play fast, play smart, and let the identity develop instead of assigning one
• What opting out of the House settlement means for roster size and scholarships
• The 50/50 math behind high school recruits and transfer additions
• What jumps off the page in a high school player, and what never will in an email
• How parents can vet a summer organization before handing over four years
• Why the fall of a freshman year is the hardest stretch in a player's baseball life

Fall Ball at Gardner-Webb

Chester says the fall is often more of a grind than the spring, because it is where everything gets put in place. His last 24 hours are a fair sample: individual work, a mental performance session with the whole team the night before, community service at the elementary school his son attends, where the players said good morning to kids arriving at 7:30, and then back on the field that afternoon. Team practice starts Thursday, with outside competition the weekend after.

At the Division I level a team gets two games against outside opponents, and many schools add a third through the international exemption that brings Canadian teams down through the Southeast on bus tours. Gardner-Webb will always take all three. A motion to allow a fourth has been tabled, and Chester hopes it passes, though what he really wants is a football rhythm: practice all week, play somebody, see where you stand, then do it again. Intrasquads are worthwhile, but by the fifth or sixth one they lose their luster.

Play Hard, Play Fast, Play Smart

He is candid that the program is coming off a poor season and that the fire is still in his belly. When he asked his team last week what their identity was, the honest answer was that they were still figuring it out. That suits him. Slogans handed out in September are cliché; identity develops as the year goes on.

The standard underneath it does not move: play hard, play fast, play smart, and win the details. Wasted minutes at practice, how the uniform is worn, how hard the team runs the bases. The scoreboard matters to him, but so does the handshake afterward, when he wants the other coach walking away saying that was difficult and those guys play hard.

"We've got to develop a lot of that. But any type of perceived talent gap, you can make up for by the way you play and the culture and cohesiveness that you build."

Roster Limits and the Decision to Opt Out

One misconception he runs into constantly is that every Division I roster is capped at 34. Schools that opted into the House settlement took on a 34-man roster limit with a maximum of 34 scholarships, plus the option to share revenue with players. Schools that opted out, Gardner-Webb among them, keep an unlimited roster under the old rule that caps baseball at 11.7 scholarships.

That was an institutional decision rather than his, and he is fine with it. A few extra spots means a few more opportunities, more internal competition, and a better read on what he actually has.

Yesterday Is History

Chester calls himself an old-school guy who misses watching the game get played without the constant conversation about transfers, exit velocity, and radar readings. His counterweight is a narrow focus on the day in front of him. The staff is deep in recruiting meetings and preparing for the spring, but he does not spend time reflecting on good seasons or worrying about tomorrow. As he puts it, he has retirement for that.

"Yesterday is history, tomorrow is a mystery, and today is a gift from God, so let's take advantage of it."

Building a Roster: Half High School, Half Transfer

Gardner-Webb's roster is always going to land near 50% high school and 50% transfer. Recruit only high school players in this era and it is difficult to stay competitive every year, and harder still to keep those players for a career. Build entirely out of the portal and the culture never sets. This year he has homegrown redshirt juniors and true seniors on the mound and in the field, plus a transfer class he is fired up about.

The calendar has changed to match. Fall means junior college and high school work, including players who were decommitted or let go in the roster crunch and are suddenly available. Things settle in November, and then May through August is transfer season. Nearly every player who enters the portal wants a national power, most will not get one, so his staff waits and processes players late.

What Gets a High School Player Noticed

A few things have to jump off the page. The player moves around the field differently than everyone else. There is instinct and baseball IQ. The little things are handled: the uniform worn right, a sprint to the position, how he runs to first, whether he can go first to third, and how he responds when it goes badly. Chester is not asking for a 6-foot-4, 220-pound frame, but he wants an athlete who is twitchy and takes care of himself. Most high school evaluations come down to athletes and hitters who can find a barrel, with catcher the only position he recruits specifically. On the mound he wants athleticism and a fast arm, because a loose arm and a good athlete give the staff something to develop into a secondary pitch and more velocity.

Getting in front of him is still an old-school process built on people he has known for two decades.

"I've got pockets of the country where I've got people that I trust. I'll tell them, who are the five guys that can help us? And it just streamlines everything."

The other door is camp. Every coach on staff works it, current players are there, and the price is kept low because the point is getting recruits on campus, not revenue. A player who belongs will be on the radar before the day is over. Meanwhile about a hundred player emails arrive daily, an assistant works through all of them and encourages camp visits, but nobody is getting an offer off a video attached to an email.

For Parents: Be Patient, Then Do the Homework

His first piece of advice for parents is patience. The rush to commit is over, and he considers the slowdown of eighth- and ninth-grade commitments the clearest positive of the portal era.

"It's really important in eighth, ninth, and into the tenth grade that there's a lot more focus on becoming the best player you can be, not on what school you could be trying to play at."

From there it is homework. Get on campuses. If the dream schools are the in-state powers, go to their camps and test the water, and if the calls do not come, work honestly toward the next level of programs. In the summer, find an organization with real college relationships and check the receipts: where have their players committed, how did those commitments actually happen, what events do they attend, and how does the organization answer the question when a parent asks it. He is careful not to knock anyone, and notes plenty of good organizations exist, but coaches go back to the wells that have produced. A senior who is still uncommitted is not in a bad spot either, because more time usually means a more educated decision.

The Freshman Fall, and Learning to Fail

Freshmen arrive in the summer taking one class, working with the strength coach, feeling like the only people on campus. Then August comes and grown men walk into the locker room. Chester tells every incoming player before they leave that summer that the fall of their freshman year will be the most difficult stretch of their baseball life.

"You're about to get broken down, and you're going to have to embrace it, and you're going to get built back up. If you stick with the process, this is not Twitter, this is not Instagram. You are not going to get instant gratification."

His approach to failure is to paint the picture before it happens, so that when it arrives he can point at it and tell the player this is the part they discussed. After that it is short memory and next play, in practice and in games, because how good the next play is depends entirely on how the last one gets handled. Sometimes the payoff is a text at night; sometimes it does not show up until October of a player's sophomore year.

The Lost Art of Playing the Game

Players keep getting better, Chester says. Better athletes, harder contact, higher velocity than when he started coaching. What has gone backward is the understanding of how to play. Very few players can bunt, execute a hit and run, or handle a double cut, and those are the things his staff has to teach every year.

A baseball game starts as one-on-one between the pitcher and the hitter, but the actions of both have to be team-based. The pitcher has eight players behind him. The hitter's job is not only to beat the pitcher; it is to outsmart the defense and hit it where they are not.

"We've created this one-on-one mentality: how hard can I throw it and how hard can I hit it, more than how can I outsmart them?"

A Walkout Song and a Final Word

Chester is a self-described 90s kid who leans country and will listen to just about anything, and he does not have a walkout song picked out. His 13-year-old daughter will have to choose it so he does not embarrass her. Ross campaigns for head coaches to get walkout music at the home plate meeting, and promises to follow up before opening day.

His closing thought is about the level itself. He loves college baseball, calls it the truest form of the game, and wants people watching the Running Bulldogs this spring play the right way.

Episode Timestamps

Tap any timestamp to jump the player straight to that moment.

• 0:00 — Introduction
• 0:39 — Life in Boiling Springs after growing up near Pittsburgh
• 2:01 — What one fall day looks like at Gardner-Webb
• 4:34 — How fall outside competition works in Division I
• 6:21 — A push for a fourth fall game, and a football-style week
• 9:26 — Letting an identity develop instead of assigning one
• 12:56 — Roster limits, the House settlement, and opting out
• 17:09 — Staying present when the noise gets loud
• 19:21 — A roster that is half high school, half transfer
• 21:22 — Two recruiting seasons and a changed calendar
• 23:05 — What jumps off the page in a high school player
• 25:20 — Getting noticed through relationships and a trusted network
• 27:15 — Why camps matter, and a hundred emails a day
• 30:06 — Advice for parents: be patient
• 32:34 — Vetting a summer organization
• 35:40 — Why the freshman fall is the hardest stretch
• 38:52 — Preparing players for failure before it arrives
• 41:03 — The lost art of understanding how to play
• 44:06 — Walkout songs, and a push for coaches to have one
• 46:46 — Final word on college baseball

---

Jim Chester is the head baseball coach at Gardner-Webb University in Boiling Springs, North Carolina. Subscribe to the Baseball Forward Podcast for more conversations with the players, coaches, and leaders elevating the next generation of the game.